How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Toledo, Ohio? (2025 Pricing Guide)

If you’re a homeowner in the Toledo area and you’re thinking about replacing your roof in 2025, one of the first questions that probably comes to mind is: how much is this going to cost? The truth is, the cost of a new roof can vary dramatically depending on several key factors—and unfortunately, not all roofing companies are upfront about what you’re actually paying for.

At Ace Roofing and Construction, we believe in transparency, integrity, and delivering a roof that will truly stand the test of time. So let’s break down what goes into the cost of a new roof in Toledo, and what you should look out for when comparing estimates from different contractors.

Average Roof Replacement Costs in 2025

In 2025, the average cost to replace a roof in the Toledo area typically ranges from $8,000 to $20,000 or more for really large roofs. That’s a big range, but there’s a good reason for it. Roofing costs are influenced by everything from the size and pitch of your roof, to the materials used, to the crew doing the work.

Let’s take a closer look at the most important cost factors—and why choosing the cheapest bid can often cost you far more in the long run.

1. Material Quality

Not all roofing materials are created equal. Some contractors will quote you a low price because they’re using the cheapest shingles and components on the market—materials that will fail prematurely or just don’t hold up under Toledo’s harsh weather conditions.

At Ace Roofing and Construction, we don’t believe in cutting corners. We use top-tier roofing systems and materials that are built to last. That includes proper-sized flashing, large drip edges, high-quality underlayment, and shingles that carry industry-leading durability ratings.

While these materials may cost a little more upfront, they dramatically extend the life of your roof—and they’re part of the reason we can confidently offer our 50-year labor and material warranty.

2. Labor: Employees vs. Sub Crews

One of the biggest hidden price variables is who’s actually installing your roof. Many big-name contractors in Toledo outsource their work to subcontractor crews. These subs often aren’t properly trained, aren't held to the same standards, and don’t have the accountability you’d expect when investing thousands into your home.

Even worse? When a sub crew improperly installs your roof, it can void your manufacturer’s warranty entirely—leaving you on the hook for repairs or even a full tear-off just a few years later.

At Ace Roofing and Construction, we never use sub crews. Every installer on your project is a trained, in-house employee, and they follow our strict quality control standards on every single job. This is a major reason why our roofs don’t fail—and why other companies call us to tear off brand-new roofs they just installed because they were put on incorrectly by underqualified crews.

3. Insurance and Licensing

Another thing that can influence price is whether the contractor has proper liability insurance, workers’ comp coverage, and all the state and local licenses required to do roofing in Toledo.

While some fly-by-night companies or “storm chasers” may offer a rock-bottom price, they often lack these essential protections. That puts you at risk as the homeowner. If an uninsured worker gets hurt on your property, you could be liable. If your roof fails, there’s little recourse.

Ace Roofing and Construction is fully licensed, bonded, and insured. We meet or exceed all state and local requirements—and we do things by the book, every time.

4. Project Timeframe and Crew Size

A well-staffed and trained roofing team can complete a tear-off and replacement faster and with more attention to detail. Cheaper contractors may show up with a skeleton crew or drag your project out over several days.

We believe your time is valuable. Our team is fully staffed and efficient, and we aim to complete most residential roofing projects in one to two days without sacrificing quality.

5. Warranty Protection

As mentioned above, not all warranties are created equal. Many companies only offer a manufacturer’s material warranty. But here’s the catch—if the roof isn’t installed perfectly, that warranty is worthless. And if the company used subs, there’s a good chance they’ll refuse to fix the problem or drag it into a costly legal battle.

Ace Roofing and Construction offers a true 50-year warranty on both labor and materials. That means you’re protected, no matter what. We’re confident in our work because we know how it's done—and we stand behind it 100%.

Why Some Roofs Fail—Even When They’re Brand New

We tear off brand-new roofs every year that were installed by some of the biggest names in Toledo roofing. Why? Because those companies prioritized profits over quality. They sent sub crews with no formal training, used cheap underlayment, cut corners on flashing and drip edge, and skipped key components of a quality installation.

The result? Leaks, blow-offs, and frustrated homeowners.

We’re different. Our primary focus is providing a quality roof at a competitive price point—without sacrificing workmanship, materials, or customer service.

Final Thoughts

If you’re shopping for a new roof in Toledo, don’t just look at the bottom line of the estimate. Ask questions. Who will actually be installing the roof? What kind of warranty is included—and is it truly backed by the company? Are they using quality materials? Are they properly licensed and insured?

Remember, a cheap roof may wind up being extremely expensive if you need a new one in a couple of years after discovering leaks everywhere...

At Ace Roofing and Construction, we’re proud to offer honest, transparent pricing and roofing systems that are built to last. We’re not the cheapest—and we’re not trying to be. But we are one of the most trusted and dependable roofing contractors in the region.

When you choose us, you’re investing in peace of mind, long-term value, and a roof that’s backed for 50 years—labor and materials included.

Ready for a roof that lasts? Contact us today for a free, no-obligation quote and discover the Ace difference for yourself.